Tuesday, May 17, 2011

Coal Dust is Complicated but Real Problem

At the City Club presentation one of SSA Marine’s hired guns challenged me on the coal dust issue.  His challenge to me was basically that if I were to find that the Northwest Clean Air Agency (please see New Business section of Board minutes) had never had a complaint about coal dust, would I stop my “rhetoric” about the problems with coal dust?  The simple answer is: No, of course not.  The challenge was clever on a certain level, but disingenuous because of the nature of coal dust and how and where it has an impact.   Coal dust—in this context—is more of a water quality issue than an air quality issue (please see Seward, Alaska). 

Coal dust is a complicated issue that impacts different systems in different ways at different levels and at different times.  For instance, coal dust is considered a toxic substance by multiple agencies and organizations when inhaled by humans.  Most people are familiar with “black lung disease” that afflicts coal miners and residents in coal towns.  But these effects require large amounts of dust in a confined space over a long period of time.  RE Sources has never mentioned black lung disease as a possible public impact of the Cherry Point coal terminal project. 


Coal dust in the context of this Cherry Point project is a problem 1) near the mines where it spews from open rails cars in a visible dust cloud; 2) when the trains are traveling at-speed or when vortices are created by other trains, man-made surfaces, or geological formations; and 3) when it is unloaded from trains, manipulated, and loaded on ships at the terminal.  That is not to say that fugitive coal dust is benign or absent at other stages in its journey from the mine to furnace to atmosphere, but these are the most important and most impactful.

Coal dust around the mines and in the first stages of transport is expelled at a monumental rate.  That means that coal dust piles up along rail lines and coats the landscape for hundreds of miles from the mines.  BNSF is currently in litigation with energy companies and mine operators over the dust issue as it fouls rail line ballast—the rocks placed around the rails and ties to allow proper drainage—and is thought by some to contribute eventually to derailments.  This region will not experience this phenomenon, but it is one of the broader impacts of this proposed project and should be considered in a responsible analysis of impacts.

Coal dust lifting off of moving trains has been studied in the US, Canada, and Australia with similar results.  Work cited in an Australian study, for instance, indicated that dust loss was very wind speed dependent with coal dust being expelled at wind speeds as low as 20 kilometers per hour (13.4 mph) and increasing nearly exponentially as speed of wind across load increases (i.e., dust loss doubles between 25 mph and 40 mph and triples between 25mph and 50 mph).  The same paper cited studies that indicated that dust increased when trains passed each other and when trains traveled through tunnels or along cliff faces; in other words any conditions that caused wind vortices. 

Photo Credit Paul K. Anderson, Chuckanut Conservancy
 Dust expelled during transit at cross load wind speeds in excess of 20 kilometers per hour is deposited near the tracks.  And while it likely causes little in the way of human impacts and is often difficult to detect, the dust impacts vegetative growth cycles and the diversity of plants, changes soil chemistry, and washes into waterways where it can physiological and genetic impacts on species such as salmon.  The level of damage to plants, soil, and water is dependent on the amount of dust and its chemical composition.  Coal dust around the Lambert’s Point Coal Terminal, for instance, has added detectable amounts of arsenic to the soils around the terminal.  In any case, coal dust in waterways tends to remove oxygen from the water column and that is not good for wetlands or aquatic creatures. 

Fugitive coal dust expelled at locales more than 100 miles from the mines is frequently discounted by terminal project proponents, but the phenomenon is very real to the folks who experience it.  Although it is mostly characterized as a nuisance rather than a human health issue, people’s lives are changed by it.  Organic gardens are fouled, pools and outdoor spaces are speckled with dust, and boats and marinas are blackened on decks and at the waterline. 

Coal terminals and other facilities that move or handle coal around the world face complaints about coal dust from Australia to India and from Seward, Alaska to Mobile, Alabama.  That also goes for those closer to home as well like Robert’s Bank near Vancouver, BC and Ridley Terminal near Prince Rupert in the same province.  Even when the facilities are doing all that they can to reduce dust, the sheer mechanics of handling or moving millions of metric tons of coal creates dust that even the most sophisticated dust control systems can only reduce but not control completely.  The areas in and around coal terminals, storage facilities, and coal fired power plants suffer as a result and as a result people react to the prospect of coal terminals again, and again, and again.
McDuffie Terminal in Mobile, AL - Currently the largest facility of its kind in North America

Cherry Point project proponents would love to discount and cloud this issue.  They claim that their facility will deal with dust in a manner that is better than all other facilities in the world.  But when asked about how they will accomplish that monumental feat while moving more materials through the same operational footprint, they are a little short on details and proven methodologies.  They simply ask us to trust them and that is just not good enough.

--Bob Ferris
RE Sources' Executive Director

56 comments:

  1. Black coal sediments also deposits in water. That has been seriously considered as harmful to our water reservoir. There is a need to emphasize on drain cleaners for the water ways.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Trắng da có nhiều phương pháp , nhưng hầu hết mọi người điều sử dụng các loại thuốc trắng da nhưng đặt ra nhiều câu hỏi quanh các loại thuốc này như thuốc uống trắng da nào hiệu quả , thuốc uống trắng da ivory caps có hại không , thuốc uống trắng da ivory caps có tốt không ? Đó là một vài câu hỏi liên quan đến thuốc làm trăng da ivory caps , cùng tìm hiểu nhé . Ngoài trắng da thì mỹ phẩm nhật bản sakura còn giúp da giữ được nét tự nhiên và chống lão hóa vì dùng kem chống lão hóa sakura , ngoài làm trắng da thì còn là kem chống nắng và giá cả thì cũng là vấn đề vì vậy có nhiều câu hỏi như mua kem chống nắng loại nào tốt ,.. Có nhiều loại nên có nhiều giá khác nhau . Nếu gót chân bị nứt nẻ thì nên dùng kem trị nứt gót chân hiệu quả neutrogena foot cream sẽ giúp bạn có được bàn chân đẹp như ý.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Simply super comments are posted here..
    luv2dj4u

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you for this guidance.its really informative for all..
    mappagoweb

    ReplyDelete
  5. Its useful to every one and keep posting mendikoetxea

    ReplyDelete
  6. What a good suggestion posted by the peoples
    mielcharlevoix

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks for the comments which the peoples are give here
    muguady

    ReplyDelete
  8. its really informative tutorial. Thank you for this tutorial nestoholic

    ReplyDelete
  9. all the words in simple way every one should understand easily onlinehispanictrends

    ReplyDelete
  10. Information's are more innovative and nice to read it
    pressfreedomcomm

    ReplyDelete
  11. Keep posting the articles,useful to every one.
    puntdegust

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thank you for this guidance.its really informative for all..
    santacruzfmradio

    ReplyDelete
  13. What a good suggestion posted by the peoples
    tedbeier

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This blog always shares nice post like this, Thats what I like about this blog. Lulubox.

      Delete
  14. Thanks for the comments which the peoples are give here
    thinkverylittle

    ReplyDelete
  15. Acquiring Custom Assignment Writing Services from a credible firm like Legitimate Assignment Writing Company ensures that you attain excellence, especially in your College Assignment Writing Services endeavors, which can be challenging in many instances.

    ReplyDelete
  16. It was an amazing article. Realy helpful.
    PLAYit For PC

    ReplyDelete
  17. Thank you for this info very helpful for me… Kinemaster Diamond APK And GB Instagram APK  My fav APk's.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Thanks alot for this informative blog. You guys are amazing and the content you providing is just mind-blowing. Also check out
    Nulled WP Plugins 2021
    clash of clans MOD APK 2021

    ReplyDelete
  19. Impressive web site, Distinguished feedback that I can tackle. Im moving forward and may apply to my current job as a pet sitter, which is very enjoyable, but I need to additional expand. Regards. buy real instagram followers

    ReplyDelete
  20. This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing blog that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. Keep up the good work - COC MOD and GBWhatsapp

    ReplyDelete
  21. Thanks for the detailed article on this topic. I would like to see more such awesome articles from you. Download GBWhatsApp APK

    ReplyDelete
  22. Thanks for the detailed article on this topic. I would like to see more such awesome articles from you. Also you can get the new and best features of GBWhatsapp which are coming in 2022- GBWhatsapp 2022 APK

    ReplyDelete
  23. Thanks for the detailed article on this topic. I would like to see more such awesome articles from you.


    FMWhatsapp APK

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thank you for sharing this. It was helpful. Keep sharing such things.
    Also I like to play DLS 2022 Mod Apk which is more fun than any other game.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Coal dust is really a serious threat and should be handled with much precision that it not affect others. fmwhatsapp

    ReplyDelete
  26. Your site is the best source of information, it was very helpful. Thanks for sharing.
    Also try Nulls Brawl Apk.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Off course!Coal dust is more of a water quality issue than an air quality issue.Alrwady read in a group post of gb whatsapp downlaod

    ReplyDelete
  28. Thanks for the detailed article on this topic. I would like to see more such awesome articles from you. And Also The New Features & Tool Of GBWhatsapp APK Has Arrived Of Year 2022 !! Get It Now -


    GBWhatsapp APK 2022


    ReplyDelete
  29. hey thanks for sharing i was looking for great post and edit version of whatsapp finnally got from you post download fm whats app and shrae in groups

    ReplyDelete
  30. It was an amazing article. Realy helpful!Forever tracking
    Use that tracker tool to trace your parcels at any place or time.

    ReplyDelete
  31. learn the facts here now bags replica gucci best site navigate here learn the facts here now visit the site

    ReplyDelete
  32. Nowadays, many people use WhatsApp to share videos, photos, audio, and much more. If you want to use WhatsApp with some extra features, then gb whatsApp apk is available to download and install on your device.

    ReplyDelete
  33. The gaming industry is always busy making special games for everyone. Everyone’s inclination towards gaming has increased due to smartphones. Nowadays, the question is not whether anyone likes gaming or not. It is a fact of life today that every mobile phone has a variety of games that must be played at some point. Temple Run 2 MOD APK DOWNLOAD

    ReplyDelete
  34. On this page is a novel proposal that I recently read about and found to be very educational.
    https://crackguru.net/office-tab-enterprise-13-10-crack/

    ReplyDelete
  35. 中國人線上看,韓劇, 日劇,陸劇,中國人線上看, 台劇,線上看 綜藝、動漫 線觀看 電影免費在 線上觀看體驗

    ReplyDelete

  36. 楓林網,楓林網电影,韓劇線上看,台劇線上看,韓劇 線上看,電影 線上看,陸劇線上看,日劇線上看,美劇線上看,港劇線上看,电影,电视剧,动漫,视频 网站,高清视频,楓林網, 楓林网, 楓林, 風林網看體驗

    ReplyDelete
  37. 独播库, 独播库,线上看,免费在线观看,电影,电视剧,动漫,视频网站,高清视美劇等熱門劇集

    ReplyDelete
  38. 隨時隨地輕綜藝、陸劇、韓劇、美劇、台劇、日劇、BL、泰劇、紀錄片等 電影線上看

    ReplyDelete
  39. 楓林网, 楓林, 風林網, 楓林網, 上看,港劇線上看,Maplestage,8maple,

    ReplyDelete