Thursday, August 25, 2011

Gateway Pacific Terminal - update August 17th

August 17th - It has been a fairly busy week already with talk of a 6-year moratorium being imposed on SSA Marine for destroying 9.1 acres of habitat that included trees, wetlands, and an archaeological site without a permit. (Thanks Jean for the posts)


http://getwhatcomplanning.blogspot.com/2011/08/heedless-destruction.html

http://getwhatcomplanning.blogspot.com/2011/08/how-would-that-six-year-moratorium-work.html

http://blogs.bellinghamherald.com/politics/politics/earthjustice-with-dnr-notice-whatcom-county-must-impose-six-year-development-ban-on-ssa-marine-land/

This week also saw one of the first broadly circulated pieces on coal and coke dropping off trains in the area. This has been covered by us before (http://blog.re-sources.org/2011/05/coal-dust-is-complicated-but-real.html) but it is nice to see it covered on KING 5 TV as well.




This week also saw an opinion piece by Marysville’s mayor about current train traffic issues and how this 30 miles of added trains would cripple an already impacted system.

http://www.pnwlocalnews.com/north_sound/mar/opinion/127464218.html

And last but not least, many of you in the Bellingham area may have gotten an e-mail from Karl Kleeman the president of the local railroad museum. Mr. Kleeman was critical of Whatcom DOCS efforts to talk about the potential health impacts of the terminal. Below is my response to Mr. Kleeman’s issues (his points are in italics). As usual, read all of this and pass it and the links along. And thank you all for you efforts, you are all doing a wonderful job.

Response to Karl Kleeman:

Dear Mr. Kleeman,

I am in receipt of your recent electronic communication regarding the coal trains. I take issue with your four points/questions (in italics) as follows:

1. How much diesel exhaust would you expect compared to the diesel exhaust
from all the trucks on I 5. Modern locomotives have some of the best clean
running diesels made. Complete burning of the fuel also makes them more
cost efficient. And of course the diesels are not moving the locomotive,
they are diesel electrics and the electric motors move the locomotive.

Yes modern diesels are more fuel efficient and emit less nitrogen and greenhouse gases than do diesel powered tractor trailer rigs. Unfortunately, when it comes to diesel particulates there is not a huge difference in the grams/ton mile of PM released (please see BNSF power point slide in http://blog.re-sources.org/2011/07/here-comes-freeway-of-air-polluting.html). Moreover, all indications are that the more we look at diesel particulates—especially those under 2.5 microns as well as the even smaller nano-particles—these very problematic health-wise. For the doctors in Whatcom County to characterize them otherwise would be irresponsible.

2. The noise from train diesels is not very significant compared with I 5 and other noise producers. The trains have to blow their horns by law to
keep people off the tracks.

Do you live near the tracks? Because for those of us who do this noise is non-trivial. We worry about its health impact as well as its impact on property values. Looking at what this project could add to an already difficult condition, one has only to multiply required horn blasts (5) by at-grade crossing (5) by number of trains at full capacity (9) by number of trips per day (2). This exercise yields 450 additional horn blast a day. Moreover, adding current traffic to projected traffic means one train every 45 minutes 24/7. This passes far beyond a trivial impact.

3. A mile long train going 20 mph, the speed limit in Bellingham will block
an intersection for 3 minutes. And if instead of saying no coal trains, we
said, put in a couple more overhead or underpass train crossings, we would
really help the traffic problem that already exists with the current train
traffic.

Your estimate on train length is short by 50% and your speeds are optimistic. Empirical data are indicating 5-8 minutes but at Post Point where these 17500 ton trains often come to a full stop and have to start up again, we are seeing blocked crossings closer to 10 minutes and even longer if another train traveling in the other direction is involved. And while it is nice to talk about overpasses as a solution, federal law puts the burden of those types of improvements (90% or more) squarely on the shoulders of the tax payer and not the railroad.

4. The coal dust thing is just nonsense. Little if any as the train passes
through Bellingham and the terminal plans the newest in containment like the
coal will be dumped in a negative pressure building, no dust released and
even the coal conveyors will be enclosed and under negative pressure.

Just because the coal dust issue is complicated and at times unpredictable does not mean it does not exist or is nonsense. What does not exist is a coal dust free coal terminal or a working example of some of the technologies suggested by SSA Marine. They claim that the place where they unload rail cars will be under negative pressure (not the conveyors), but that leaves 80 acres of open mounds as well as dust scattered during handling and by the repeated movement of the elephant snout or snorkel loaders as they iteratively move from hold to hold to load ships evenly. Every place we have seen this technology employed we have seen decks covered with coal dust which ultimately finds its way into the water column. And all major coal terminals in North America have coal dust issues some of them currently under litigation.

I understand your love of trains. I love them too and see them as a solution when used appropriately and in the proper scale. This project violates both of those conditions. Rejection of this project is in no way a no-confidence vote on trains, but rather a condemnation of a project whose scale and cargo threaten the quality of life and health of folks all along the 624 mile delivery route in Washington State. Let’s stick to the facts and keep trains on the right track.

Bob Ferris

16 comments:

  1. THANK YOU SO much for sharing the post. Wanting more from you. wpa wps tester wifi master key fake gps

    ReplyDelete
  2. This also gives the students some time to review them and ask for revisions, if needed. You can trust our academic ghostwriters completely to get best quality write-ups including case studies, research proposals, dissertations and assignment help in melbourne, and more.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It is understandable that one is more confident when their task is in the hands of the Professional Essay Writing Help than a novice; thus, one hires Essay Writing Asssignment Help Writer who delivers the ideal Custom Essay Paper.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This website is my breathing in, real fantastic design and perfect content. Looking for some inspiration for your next trip? Find great vacation ideas and inspiration from Things to do with your source for the web's best reviews and travel ...

    ReplyDelete

  5. That we call a real informative blog. It is very nice and the data you used in it is very useful for us. I am here only due to your informative posts. Thanks for shearing and keep on sharing.The Mobile App Development Dubai provides good app development service.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I will carefully read the issues you just shared, I find there are some places that are not very clear

    MAPinr OFFLINE For PC

    ReplyDelete
  7. Personal statement & editing services have become very popular for students searching for college admission writing services as they engage the best online Personal Statement Writing Services.

    ReplyDelete

  8. Hey dear admin, Your article is very informative and fresh. It is nice to read such high-quality information. It is attractive information on your post, thank you for taking the time and share with everyone. Assignment Help Melbourne

    ReplyDelete
  9. I'm truly dazzled about the information you give in your articles. I should state am exceptionally overpowered by your entire story. It is difficult to get such quality data online these days. I anticipate remaining here for quite a while.

    office.com/setup

    office.com/setup

    mcafee.com/activate

    mcafee.com/activate

    ReplyDelete
  10. Good your article is very helpful for me. You make it easy. I appreciate your work and knowledge. I will recommend theseinformations to others, more people will get the information and help. For additional informationto keep my self update (package point) guide is well known in updates and also about Mash Stream. keep sharing your informative and unique knowledge with us. i will wait for you more unique articles.

    ReplyDelete
  11. du hoc canada vnsava
    Chuyên du học Canada Công ty tư vấn du học Canada nào tốt
    Điều kiện du học Canada 2021
    Học bổng du học Canada vnsava

    vnsava
    Thông tin du học Canada mới nhất

    vnsava
    Chính sách du học Canada 2020
    vnsava
    Du học Canada bao nhiêu tiền Việt
    Học bổng du học Canada 2020
    vnsava
    Du học Canada 2020
    Nhất ký du học Canada
    vnsava
    Du học Canada nên học ngành gì
    công ty tư vấn du học Canada vnsava, chính sách điều kiện định cư Canada, học bổng, chi phí, điều kiện xin visa canada
    #vnsava
    @vnsava
    vnsava
    vnsava
    vnsava

    ReplyDelete
  12. We are one among the Professional Website Design Services. Our objective is to deliver clients with trending solutions that add values to their webpages and applications. We are web designing services company and we have efficient team of experts who are keen to complete the project within specified period. Our HTML5 developers are up to date in latest designing tools and technologies to build interactive websites. If you are looking for responsive website development company also you can hire best website designers we are here to help you.

    ReplyDelete